You know more about the code and how it works than I do, I just don't want to see a situation where we start heading one direction that people don't like.
If you can guarantee that then changes may be a good thing but I still can't see how I will benefit or anyone else really with most of this.
I realize that I can't go making changes willy-nilly and make people like them. Anything major that affects gameplay would either be an option (like mAAp TeamView) or it would be voted on.
The thing that sparked controversy was the AA3 gun sounds. I think that would be cool as they're probably recorded with better equipment and they're probably just better sounds all around. The problem is matching the reload sound to the reload animation. Things like this would make changing sounds impractical. Combine that with users not wanting it and it means that it won't happen.
I know you say that things have been overcome by time and technology but that's not always true. Skrewy has capped internet and if he needs to re-download, having less stuff to re-download is worthwhile to him. Also, if we were to "pimp" maps with lighting and effects (snow on bridge?), it would use more CPU and video memory. Since AA uses a single-core, we have to balance that stuff.
Anyway, bottom line is, I have plenty of work in mAAp and trying to get physics working that the benefits of merging right now aren't as high priority as a new mAAp release. I have plenty of other things to do than to mess with gameplay and piss users off