Forum

ASSIST, AMERICA'S ARMY COMMUNITY - RELIVE THE GLORY DAYS OF AMERICA'S ARMY 2.5

Author Topic: What Makes an Excellent Sound Card?  (Read 38662 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Offline Spanky

  • <?php echo $opinion .' is better.'; ?>
  • Administrator
  • Posts like a Spanky!
  • *
  • Posts: 10,893
    • View Profile
    • NatesComp.com
  • AA: tigobitties
Re: What Makes an Excellent Sound Card?
« Reply #30 on: Wednesday, April 11, 2012, 01:02:47 AM »
Blue brings up good points. There's DIY kits on PartsExpress. While they probably won't compare to a vintage system, it's fun to DIY and read what other builds people are making with similar parts. Buying used vintage can be quite a hassle with having to replace parts anyway (requiring soldering skills or paying someone else to do it). I too think it would be fun to build my own speakers, starting from a kit and modding more and more. There's TONS of designs out there and plenty of help on various forums as well.

Nate I may be interested in buying a final product off you come summer
What...
It's like shaving your pubes to make your junk look bigger.
Might look bigger, but it aint.....

Offline guily6669

  • Sound Engineer
  • Full Member
  • ***
  • Posts: 204
  • What the heck?
    • View Profile
  • AA: guily6669
Re: What Makes an Excellent Sound Card?
« Reply #31 on: Wednesday, April 11, 2012, 06:37:46 AM »
Well about creative they claim...


"Creative’s Sound Blaster X-Fi Xtreme Audio gives an experience beyond studio quality with MP3 music and movies! Featuring award-winning X-Fi technologies, X-Fi Crystalizer restores the details and vibrance lost during MP3 and DIVX compression, breathing life back into any audio, while X-Fi CMSS-3D expands stereo music and movies into amazing surround sound. Effective over virtually any speakers, including stereo speakers, Sound Blaster X-Fi Xtreme Audio even provides unbelievable surround sound over normal headphones!"

That's what I was saying... it's not entirely 100% true, but it does effect, the cpu changed the modulation, it kinda makes the bass sound lower frequency and the highs sound very high.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

And about amps, those old amps are no match against newer ones... Any good hi-fi amp of like 100w here cost around 500€ (660$) in pixmania which is the place you get lower prices, but they have so much more fidelity than the old amps.

And about my father's amp killing headphones is not a malfunction, it's just that at full volume it make any kind of headphones to sound almost like a speaker because it had a pretty huge speaker output that killed your hears too lol (But on low volume ur safe).

And I actually connected one of the good "KEF" good old speakers in my logitech and they sounded better than in the hi-fi amp (just not as loud, cause they are lot more than 100w rms, and the logitech output is 60wrms, but it still kicked some good sound quality and pretty damn loud with good bass). BTW, the speakers are HARD WOOD. But you can buy newer ones in titanium with the best acoustic wood out there, the problem is they will cost like HELL.

Oh and also, old expensive speakers are just...speakers. Nowadays expensive speakers are made of titanium and other good and better materials and some use neodymnium, which is a permanent magnet (rare material on earth). While a normal speaker loses magnet field over time, those never lose it and always kick in pretty bad ass...

ps: I like JBL, that's what I bought for the car, and it killed all my friends speakers at same price level.
I got some speakers left from my old sound system u can buy mans

4 of these (SR, SL, SBL, SBR)
https://servicesales.sel.sony.com/ecom/accessories/web/viewItemDetail.do?operation=getItemDetail&itemID=675086&category=4&categoryName=Home%20Audio

and the centre speaker for the system, part number: SS-CNP5000 which I couldnt find a page for, heres some copy pasta about it

atm they are just chilling in my room taking up space
Yack, I hate sonny sound, in the car huge power subs and speakers, sonny is considered total GARBAGE...
Keep Cool
« Last Edit: Wednesday, April 11, 2012, 06:52:28 AM by guily6669 »

Offline Koden

  • Cogito Ergo Khodohn
  • Global Moderator
  • Epic Poster
  • *
  • Posts: 2,333
  • Hmmm rainbows.
    • View Profile
Re: What Makes an Excellent Sound Card?
« Reply #32 on: Wednesday, April 11, 2012, 13:22:43 PM »
Well about creative they claim...


"Creative’s Sound Blaster X-Fi Xtreme Audio gives an experience beyond studio quality with MP3 music and movies! Featuring award-winning X-Fi technologies, X-Fi Crystalizer restores the details and vibrance lost during MP3 and DIVX compression, breathing life back into any audio, while X-Fi CMSS-3D expands stereo music and movies into amazing surround sound. Effective over virtually any speakers, including stereo speakers, Sound Blaster X-Fi Xtreme Audio even provides unbelievable surround sound over normal headphones!"

That's what I was saying... it's not entirely 100% true, but it does effect, the cpu changed the modulation, it kinda makes the bass sound lower frequency and the highs sound very high.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------


Visual example for a comparable concept of loosing details in a block of data, no matter it being an image, a sound clip, or even text, for what it matters.

Starting only with the image on the right, do you think you can precisely take back any detail (even 1 pixel) of the original image on the left? You can't, because you just don't have the data. You can even fake or do a process called pixel binning to simulate a more accurate representation, but it's where all it ends. You can fake a wider representation of a sound clip but it will sound for what it is, a distort rendition in comparison to the original.

« Last Edit: Wednesday, April 11, 2012, 13:26:54 PM by Koden »

Offline Spanky

  • <?php echo $opinion .' is better.'; ?>
  • Administrator
  • Posts like a Spanky!
  • *
  • Posts: 10,893
    • View Profile
    • NatesComp.com
  • AA: tigobitties
Re: What Makes an Excellent Sound Card?
« Reply #33 on: Wednesday, April 11, 2012, 13:26:52 PM »
*EDIT* Koden made a point that I tried making earlier but his execution was better.

Of course Creative is saying that. They want to sell more! The question is, why are you listening to MP3's in the first place? FLAC or GTFO. As for hating Sony speakers, I don't think they've ever made anything good in speakers but you can't rate modern stuff. Same for JBL. No manufacturer makes them like they used to.

Car audio doesn't count either as most people there just want bass and nothing else. Not to mention all the reflections inside a car and the ambient noise when driving, it's far from ideal for listening.

Vintage Sony amps are fantastic if you ever have the chance to listen to one.

As far as modern materials in speakers, I don't know what the advantages are but I do know that modern speakers don't sound as good as vintage ones. It's a fact. It's why 40 year old speakers cost so much. A lot of the JBL speakers from back then were built without a budget. Meaning, the best they could possibly make. What manufacturer does that now? It's all about Made in China at a low budget. I challenge you to try and find a modern speaker that's made in the USA, not just assembled in the USA with Chinese components.

Why would you crank headphones that high on a receiver? That's just abuse.

If you ever have the chance, try a real stereo setup. None of this multichannel crap. Somehow get a hold of some 3-way vintage speakers and an amplifier capable of driving them properly. I KNOW for a fact that your Logitech system is highly lacking mids. Those little satelite speakers are fine for highs and the subwoofer puts out bloated lows but you're not getting mids from anywhere. I know, I had a Logitech setup and it's absolutely night and day difference between it and a real speaker & amplifier setup.

I had a HUGE 5.1 Dell setup where the amp/subwoofer was larger and heavier than a desktop computer:

I hated it, even after using it for a week trying to get used to it and tweaking it. I was using my X-Fi card at the time too. It was way too loud and those satelite speakers just can't output a decent dynamic range at all. When you have good speakers, you don't need a subwoofer. They're really only for multichannel home theater enthusiasts that need the big boom and BIC makes some pretty good subwoofers for that purpose.

I'm really not trying to sound all high and mighty and that MY WAY IS THE BEST WAY. I'm just simply talking from experience. I've had a lot of those "gamer" components and I don't have any of them anymore. I've reached a point where I'm 100% happy with my audio setup.

I hear details in music and games that I've never heard before. One minor silly example is how the M16 shot in AA echoes on for several seconds after you fire. I hear things with great clarity. Properly placed and angled speakers allow you to have an experience that I can only describe as up front and personal. You don't have to crank the volume to hear details, it's like the audio is being piped directly from the speakers into your brain. It doesn't sound like it's coming from any specific direction. That's the only way I can describe it.
It's like shaving your pubes to make your junk look bigger.
Might look bigger, but it aint.....

Offline Alex

Re: What Makes an Excellent Sound Card?
« Reply #34 on: Wednesday, April 11, 2012, 14:34:33 PM »
The question is, why are you listening to MP3's in the first place? FLAC or GTFO.
Meh, all of my music is mp3. I've heard FLAC files, and they do sound better, but it's not really worth it for the file size. Not to mention my Zune doesn't support FLAC files. I get no more enjoyment out of FLAC files than I do out of high quality MP3 files (320kbps) The difference is there, but I'm not going to waste a ton of space for a small quality increase. It's also all about convenience. My Zune doesn't support FLAC files, and even if it did, it wouldn't have enough room to hold my entire music collection. That is a big problem. And even if it did, I'm not willing to spend hundreds on headphones just to hear the quality increase FLAC brings. It doesn't make sense.

As for speakers, I don't know much about them. The only speakers I have is a Kicker ZK350 Zune dock and 4 new speakers I just bought for my car. 2 rear Rockford 6x9 speakers and 2 front Kenwood 6.5 speakers(old ones sounded like shit). No need for a subwoofer as I don't listen to anything that is supposed to be bass heavy. My speakers provide way more than enough bass.  You can talk about how they aren't the best quality all you want, but they sound great to me and I didn't spend all that much money. I think the same thing applies to these computer sound cards. Sure they may not be the best like some claim, but I'm willing to bet they cost much less than the super high end amps and what not. It's all about value for your money.

Offline Koden

  • Cogito Ergo Khodohn
  • Global Moderator
  • Epic Poster
  • *
  • Posts: 2,333
  • Hmmm rainbows.
    • View Profile
Re: What Makes an Excellent Sound Card?
« Reply #35 on: Wednesday, April 11, 2012, 14:43:50 PM »
Meh, all of my music is mp3. I've heard FLAC files, and they do sound better, but it's not really worth it for the file size. Not to mention my Zune doesn't support FLAC files. I get no more enjoyment out of FLAC files than I do out of high quality MP3 files (320kbps) The difference is there, but I'm not going to waste a ton of space for a small quality increase. It's also all about convenience. My Zune doesn't support FLAC files, and even if it did, it wouldn't have enough room to hold my entire music collection. That is a big problem. And even if it did, I'm not willing to spend hundreds on headphones just to hear the quality increase FLAC brings. It doesn't make sense.

As for speakers, I don't know much about them. The only speakers I have is a Kicker ZK350 Zune dock and 4 new speakers I just bought for my car. 2 rear Rockford 6x9 speakers and 2 front Kenwood 6.5 speakers(old ones sounded like shit). No need for a subwoofer as I don't listen to anything that is supposed to be bass heavy. My speakers provide way more than enough bass.  You can talk about how they aren't the best quality all you want, but they sound great to me and I didn't spend all that much money. I think the same thing applies to these computer sound cards. Sure they may not be the best like some claim, but I'm willing to bet they cost much less than the super high end amps and what not. It's all about value for your money.

It's just a matter of sound quality across the line from the source to the output peripheral of choice, if you have something that can render out a Flac in a faithful way, then you would notice the difference, otherwise you wouldn't notice a huge difference between that and a 160hz sampled mp3.

On the other hand it also matters what kind of music you listen of course.
« Last Edit: Wednesday, April 11, 2012, 14:46:17 PM by Koden »

Offline Alex

Re: What Makes an Excellent Sound Card?
« Reply #36 on: Wednesday, April 11, 2012, 14:52:14 PM »
It's just a matter of sound quality across the line from the source to the output peripheral of choice, if you have something that can render out a Flac in a faithful way, then you would notice the difference, otherwise you wouldn't notice a huge difference between that and a 160hz sampled mp3.

On the other hand it also matters what kind of music you listen of course.
Yeah, that's kinda my point. I don't plan on buy a sound card or amp and an expensive pair of headphones just to enjoy FLAC files. It's not worth it for the price I would have to pay.

Offline Spanky

  • <?php echo $opinion .' is better.'; ?>
  • Administrator
  • Posts like a Spanky!
  • *
  • Posts: 10,893
    • View Profile
    • NatesComp.com
  • AA: tigobitties
Re: What Makes an Excellent Sound Card?
« Reply #37 on: Wednesday, April 11, 2012, 17:02:50 PM »
I have some 320KBs MP3's too. I just try to get FLAC whenever possible. MP3 is necessary for portable devices, I have 128KBs on my phone but only because there's no difference due to the DAC/headphone amp being utter shit.

But on your desktop or laptop, there's no reason not to have FLAC. I have some FLAC songs that are 100MB each :)

Anyway, I brought it up for Guily who seems to be interested in quality yet listens to MP3's.
It's like shaving your pubes to make your junk look bigger.
Might look bigger, but it aint.....

Offline Spanky

  • <?php echo $opinion .' is better.'; ?>
  • Administrator
  • Posts like a Spanky!
  • *
  • Posts: 10,893
    • View Profile
    • NatesComp.com
  • AA: tigobitties
Re: What Makes an Excellent Sound Card?
« Reply #38 on: Wednesday, April 11, 2012, 17:05:21 PM »
FLAC pulls the data off the CD perfectly. FLAC = CD quality. MP3 is only about 1/3 the bitrate of normal FLAC but it's done in a way that makes it seem good.
It's like shaving your pubes to make your junk look bigger.
Might look bigger, but it aint.....

Offline Koden

  • Cogito Ergo Khodohn
  • Global Moderator
  • Epic Poster
  • *
  • Posts: 2,333
  • Hmmm rainbows.
    • View Profile
Re: What Makes an Excellent Sound Card?
« Reply #39 on: Wednesday, April 11, 2012, 17:20:09 PM »
and all my stuff gets put on my ipod too, along with photos of my penis. mp3 ftw. i'll use flac after I get this in a few weeks time.

http://www.pccasegear.com/index.php?main_page=product_info&cPath=211&products_id=17422

Are you trying to set the record for placing genitalia related terms in every possible (unrelated) statement or what?

Offline Spanky

  • <?php echo $opinion .' is better.'; ?>
  • Administrator
  • Posts like a Spanky!
  • *
  • Posts: 10,893
    • View Profile
    • NatesComp.com
  • AA: tigobitties
Re: What Makes an Excellent Sound Card?
« Reply #40 on: Wednesday, April 11, 2012, 17:31:20 PM »
and all my stuff gets put on my ipod too, along with photos of my penis. mp3 ftw. i'll use flac after I get this in a few weeks time.

http://www.pccasegear.com/index.php?main_page=product_info&cPath=211&products_id=17422

There's better for less $$. http://audio-gd.com
It's like shaving your pubes to make your junk look bigger.
Might look bigger, but it aint.....

Offline BlueBlaster

  • Epic Poster
  • ******
  • Posts: 2,428
    • View Profile
Re: What Makes an Excellent Sound Card?
« Reply #41 on: Wednesday, April 11, 2012, 17:40:10 PM »
There's also the DAC from maverick audio. I only know of this because of Spanky.



Offline guily6669

  • Sound Engineer
  • Full Member
  • ***
  • Posts: 204
  • What the heck?
    • View Profile
  • AA: guily6669
Re: What Makes an Excellent Sound Card?
« Reply #42 on: Wednesday, April 11, 2012, 18:21:21 PM »
FLAC pulls the data off the CD perfectly. FLAC = CD quality. MP3 is only about 1/3 the bitrate of normal FLAC but it's done in a way that makes it seem good.
I don't like FLAC. Only have nirvana discography in FLAC, and i think it takes like 2GB or some crap...

And actually sometimes I even prefer to encode my music as .mp3 128kbs at 48hz, than having it at higher rate samples like 300 and something...

About the speakers, well I do prefer quality of nowadays. While an expensive system from the 80's are just normal speakers... An expensive system nowadays comes with like 5 or even more different speakers as a single speaker in a vintage WOOD and accomplished by a powerfull sub. So 5 different speakers, means each one will reproduce only a certain frequency, so that the speakers don't have to lose all their power trying to reproduce every frequency like old systems...

Also nowadays you have special coil cases wich inside has like a labyrinth (if that's how you say it)... Nowadays some expensive ones uses titanium which is a pretty special material also neodymium  which is pretty rare.
Visual example for a comparable concept of loosing details in a block of data, no matter it being an image, a sound clip, or even text, for what it matters.

Starting only with the image on the right, do you think you can precisely take back any detail (even 1 pixel) of the original image on the left? You can't, because you just don't have the data. You can even fake or do a process called pixel binning to simulate a more accurate representation, but it's where all it ends. You can fake a wider representation of a sound clip but it will sound for what it is, a distort rendition in comparison to the original.


Well it may not physically restore the quality, but what it does, is that the crappy compressed songs which are dead songs (sound that has only lower frequencies but poor mids and highs), are listened they way they used to be played before the compression or even have more bass and still with more mids and highs than the original...

ps: if it affects.... yes it does (somes like it, somes don't).
Vintage Sony amps are fantastic if you ever have the chance to listen to one.

As far as modern materials in speakers, I don't know what the advantages are but I do know that modern speakers don't sound as good as vintage ones. It's a fact. It's why 40 year old speakers cost so much. A lot of the JBL speakers from back then were built without a budget. Meaning, the best they could possibly make. What manufacturer does that now? It's all about Made in China at a low budget. I challenge you to try and find a modern speaker that's made in the USA, not just assembled in the USA with Chinese components.

Why would you crank headphones that high on a receiver? That's just abuse.

If you ever have the chance, try a real stereo setup. None of this multichannel crap. Somehow get a hold of some 3-way vintage speakers and an amplifier capable of driving them properly. I KNOW for a fact that your Logitech system is highly lacking mids. Those little satelite speakers are fine for highs and the subwoofer puts out bloated lows but you're not getting mids from anywhere. I know, I had a Logitech setup and it's absolutely night and day difference between it and a real speaker & amplifier setup.

I had a HUGE 5.1 Dell setup where the amp/subwoofer was larger and heavier than a desktop computer:

I hated it, even after using it for a week trying to get used to it and tweaking it. I was using my X-Fi card at the time too. It was way too loud and those satelite speakers just can't output a decent dynamic range at all. When you have good speakers, you don't need a subwoofer. They're really only for multichannel home theater enthusiasts that need the big boom and BIC makes some pretty good subwoofers for that purpose.

I'm really not trying to sound all high and mighty and that MY WAY IS THE BEST WAY. I'm just simply talking from experience. I've had a lot of those "gamer" components and I don't have any of them anymore. I've reached a point where I'm 100% happy with my audio setup.

I hear details in music and games that I've never heard before. One minor silly example is how the M16 shot in AA echoes on for several seconds after you fire. I hear things with great clarity. Properly placed and angled speakers allow you to have an experience that I can only describe as up front and personal. You don't have to crank the volume to hear details, it's like the audio is being piped directly from the speakers into your brain. It doesn't sound like it's coming from any specific direction. That's the only way I can describe it.
Actually non of the old amplifiers are a match for any good amplifier of nowadays, everything is processed with special cpu's, better improved components (mosfets...3rd generation japanese condensers....).

I actually had a music table in my house for over a year that had like 20 500w professional outputs and two huge JBL 1000w RMS professional speakers, and I never heard any old system beating this one...

Specially you can put it on full volume with no source and you won't hear the bzzzzz crappy sound like old amplifiers...


ps: But I still prefer the sound of my logitech Z5500 digital to the more than 10K dollars amplifier I had here for one special reason... You can put the Z5500 at 40db and it will always sound like if you had a good amount of power like with the bigger speakers on higher volume... hint: (SUBWOOFER). And actually the logitech is not that bad on the mids, it's nothing good on the high frequencies, but I had the creative 2.1 special version I have wich have a very high frequency, and everything gets perfect.

ps2: And I prefer a billion times the sounds in the PC those days with a good sound card, using some true bad ass 50mm driver Headphones with neodymnium magnets, it's way more sound quality than you could ever have wanted...
Keep Cool
« Last Edit: Wednesday, April 11, 2012, 19:05:16 PM by guily6669 »

Offline Spanky

  • <?php echo $opinion .' is better.'; ?>
  • Administrator
  • Posts like a Spanky!
  • *
  • Posts: 10,893
    • View Profile
    • NatesComp.com
  • AA: tigobitties
Re: What Makes an Excellent Sound Card?
« Reply #43 on: Wednesday, April 11, 2012, 18:40:53 PM »
I'm glad you believe what you do Guily. It leaves the quality products for the rest of us that enjoy them.
It's like shaving your pubes to make your junk look bigger.
Might look bigger, but it aint.....

Offline guily6669

  • Sound Engineer
  • Full Member
  • ***
  • Posts: 204
  • What the heck?
    • View Profile
  • AA: guily6669
Re: What Makes an Excellent Sound Card?
« Reply #44 on: Wednesday, April 11, 2012, 18:52:12 PM »
I'm glad you believe what you do Guily. It leaves the quality products for the rest of us that enjoy them.
Read up the rest of my post...

I know about the budget and the fact that almost everything nowadays is made in china... but that doesn't count on the expensive vintage newer technology models, there are lot's built out of china with specialized people...

And then old amps are awesome to...... kill fuses and specially condensers (it uses old components which are no match against our new materials).

Nowadays there are some even special capacitors which can solder things just by using them and have a even bigger energy density than even what we though it was possible for their size. You can see them on youtube that ppl bought for experiences...

And about car amplifier, piooner is one of the best. Their new best amplifier (_I think it's 1000w) they claim it doesn't heat up and have the highest efficiency I ever seen, it's almost 100% (they can be lying, or have really used some crazy ass components).

Oh and my father's amp I think it's something like this:



And the speakers I tested on my logitech was something like this:


But I wanted to test my bro's professional speakers in the Z5500, but they have that crap professional input  >:(.

ps: Just like in PC nowadays you can buy +gold pcu's which have more than 90% of energy efficency (WHY? because of new improved components)...
Keep Cool
« Last Edit: Wednesday, April 11, 2012, 19:01:54 PM by guily6669 »

 

Download Assist

×

Download Game Client

Important: Battletracker no longer exists. However, old Battletracker accounts may still work. You can create a new 25Assist account here

Download Server Manager